Free Will and God’s Decree
Concern and comfort mark the Westminster Confession’s opening line of its third chapter on God’s eternal decree: “God, from all eternity, did, by the most wise and holy counsel of his own will, freely, and unchangeably ordain whatsoever comes to pass” (3:1a). On the one hand, since these words were written, they have instilled a sense of comfort in the hearts of many believers. Christians take solace in the knowledge that nothing happens to them apart from God’s will. In the words of Samuel Rodigast’s seventeenth-century hymn:
Whate’er my God ordains is right:
his holy will abideth;
I will be still, whate’er he doth,
And follow where he guideth.
He is my God; though dark my road,
he holds me that I shall not fall:
wherefore to him I leave it all.
The opening line of the third chapter captures an important biblical truth, namely, that God is sovereign over everything that unfolds in the creation.
On the other hand, as comforting as the truth of God’s sovereignty might be, questions arise regarding the relationship between God’s comprehensive decree and human freedom. If God sovereignly ordains all that comes to pass, how can humans make free decisions? Are we not merely marionettes dangling beneath the strings of God’s decree, pulling our wills to and fro? An immediate answer comes in a second phrase from chapter three’s first paragraph: “Yet so, as thereby neither is God the author of sin, nor is violence offered to the will of the creatures; nor is the liberty or contingency of second causes taken away, but rather established” (3:1b). The Confession makes three important qualifications concerning God’s sovereign decree. First, God is not the author of sin. Second, God does not force anyone to perform any action. Third, God’s decree does not rob humans of their freedom but is the very ground of their freedom. Does the Bible affirm these three points of qualification? Yes, it does.
This collection of essays, written by faculty from Reformed Theological Seminary, presents an essential, single-volume guide to the Westminster Confession of Faith for modern audiences.
God ordains whatsoever comes to pass, and yet he is thrice holy (Isa. 6:1-8), and there is no shadow of turning within him (James 1:17). This means that even if we struggle to understand how God’s decree relates to human freedom, we know that God is not the author of sin. Moreover, God holding sinners accountable for their sin means that humans both commit sin and are accountable to God for it. It would be unjust for God to hold someone accountable for sin if he forced the person to sin. This would be unjust and is contrary to God’s holy, upright character. At the same time, the only way that something can exist is if God decrees its existence: the triune God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is the God “who is and who was and who is to come” (Rev. 1:4). In other words, the triune God is the great I am (Ex. 3:14). God existed before all created things, and only God’s decree brought all things into existence from non-existence: “For you created all things, and by your will they existed and were created” (Rev. 4:11). God must first will for something to exist; he must decree a thing’s existence before it can exist. To borrow words from Paul, God “gives life to the dead and calls into existence the things that do not exist” (Rom. 4:17).
If God sovereignly decrees and then creates all things, how can humans be free? Does the Bible say anything about this relationship? The Bible does speak to this issue, but it does not explain it. For example, when Joseph’s brothers came to him seeking forgiveness for the sin of selling him into slavery, Joseph told his brothers: “As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive, as they are today” (Gen. 50:20). Joseph did not excuse his brothers’ sin. He did not say, “It’s ok. God meant it for good, therefore you are not responsible for your treacherous betrayal.” Joseph also did not say, “God tried to pick up the pieces and make the best out of a difficult situation since you sold me into slavery.” He affirmed God’s sovereignty, “God meant it for good,” and also held his brothers accountable for their sin, “You meant evil against me.” Joseph does not explain how these things fit together, but he does affirm the reality and compatibility of both truths. The Westminster Confession carefully traces the lines of these biblical truths.
If God sovereignly decrees and then creates all things, how can humans be free?
Divine Sovereignty and Human Responsibility
Another place where we find this same truth affirmed is in Christ’s crucifixion. Peter told the crowd at Pentecost: “This Jesus, delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God, you crucified and killed by the hands of lawless men” (Acts 2:23). Once again, Peter did not say, “Since God delivered up Jesus according to his definite plan, you are not responsible for your actions.” Nor did Peter say, “You killed Jesus by lawless hands, which forced God to make the best out of a bad situation.” Like Joseph before him, Peter held both truths together: God is sovereign (“Jesus [was] delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God”), and humans are responsible (“You crucified and killed by the hands of lawless men.”) Peter does not explain how these two truths work together, but he nevertheless affirms both, which is what the Westminster Confession does when it says that God did “freely, and unchangeably ordain whatsoever comes to pass,” and yet he does so in a way that “thereby neither is God the author of sin, nor is violence offered to the will of the creatures.”
Is there a way, though, that we might catch a glimpse into how divine sovereignty and human responsibility fit together? The Confession provides a clue when it says that the “decree of God” is “the first Cause” of all things that come to pass (5:1) and that his decree is the reason why “second causes” (3:1) can exist. God is the primary cause of all things, but humans are secondary causes. How do primary and secondary causes relate to each other? If we liken God to the author of a novel, as the author he sovereignly determines the whole story from the least to the greatest detail. Within the world of the story, however, all of the human characters freely choose all of their actions even though the author “decreed” each and every action they choose. The author’s power to cause events within the story is on a completely different level than the powers of the characters in the novel. God as author of a novel is an illustration that helps us to see how God sovereignly ordains all things while at the same time preserving human freedom. God’s ability to cause events is on a completely different level than our human ability to cause events. As the author of history, God ordains whatsoever comes to pass, whether Joseph’s treacherous kidnapping into slavery or Christ’s crucifixion. But in these circumstances God did not force Joseph’s brothers or the people of Jerusalem to commit their sinful acts. He decreed the events but the sinful humans were the authors of the sins.
In the end, we must realize that understanding the relationship between divine sovereignty and human responsibility is not simply an intellectual parlor trick or moving pieces of a puzzle around the table until the otherwise fractured picture of life makes sense. Rather, understanding the decree of our triune God ensures we have a safe haven in the midst of life’s storms. We know that no matter what befalls us, every event, from the least to the greatest, comes to us by the sovereign will of God. At the same time, we also know that God does not force anyone to sin, but he also does not sit idly by as a spectator, wringing his hands, trying to make the best of a bad situation. God’s sovereign decree ensures our salvation as well as his uninterrupted fatherly care and love for us in Christ through the Spirit. In Paul’s well-known and beautiful words, only a God who ordains whatsoever comes to pass can ensure that “neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us form the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Rom. 8:38–39).
J. V. Fesko is the editor of The Westminster Confession of Faith: A Comprehensive Commentary on Its History, Theology, and Application.
Related Articles
If God Is Sovereign, Why Is There Evil in the World?
The clearest example that even moral evil fits into the designs of God is the crucifixion of Christ. Who would deny that the betrayal of Jesus by Judas was a morally evil act?
You Are Free from the Burden of Being Sovereignly in Control
What does it mean that the Bible teaches that God is sovereign? It means that God alone determines all that will happen and rules how everything will happen.
Podcast: Answering Hard Questions about Predestination and Free Will (Andy Naselli)
Andy Naselli answers a few of the most common questions about the doctrine of predestination, including what the Bible really says about it and what impact this teaching may have on the idea of free will.
How God’s Sovereignty Steadies a Fearful Mom
Often, behind our fears is this realization that as much as we want to be in control or sometimes think that we are, at the end of the day, ultimately, we’re not in control.


