I seek a coach every couple of years to bring a fresh set of eyes to my leadership, especially in areas where I need improvement. I’ve hired coaches to help with church staff development, preaching, business leadership, and multi-site strategies. All of my coaches were worth the investment.
Coaching is everywhere in ministry now. We offer individualized ministry coaching at Church Answers. There are a couple of spots open right now if you’re interested. A pastor has never had more access to guidance, but access alone is not improvement. Just because you have a coach does not mean you are coachable.
A team of researchers in Australia recently reviewed fifty years of studies on this question in the journal Sports Medicine. They were studying athletes, not pastors, but the findings transfer. They call the trait “coachability” and define it as a person’s willingness and ability to seek out, receive, and act on feedback.
Here’s the part that is relevant to most of us. Coachability was long treated as a fixed personality trait. You either had it, or you didn’t. Researchers now understand it as a set of skills that can be developed. So the pastor who is hard to coach today does not have to remain that way. The researchers identified six components, which I’ve adapted for the pastorate.
1. Attention. You cannot act on advice you never heard. If your mind drifts while your mentor speaks, nothing else on this list matters. Sometimes the problem is a bad habit of not paying attention. Sometimes the problem is that you don’t believe this person has anything to teach you. If that’s the case, you need either a change of heart or a different coach.
2. Willingness. Hearing is not applying. Two things block application: overconfidence and inertia. Overconfidence says, “I’m already doing this well.” Inertia says, “He’s right, but rearranging my week is a lot of work.” Both end in the same place: inaction. Pastors are especially prone to the first one. We spend all week telling other people what to do. It’s hard to have someone do the same for us.
3. Persistence. Good counsel often fails the first time you try it. New systems feel worse before they feel better. A new preaching calendar feels awkward in month one. A restructured staff meeting is clumsy until about the sixth week. If you abandon the plan after one rough month, you’ll never know whether it would have worked. Most pastors don’t quit on the coach. They quit on the advice.
4. Seeking. There is a difference between accepting feedback and going after it. The pastors who improve fastest ask for input nobody offered. They debrief the sermon on Monday. They ask a staff member, “What did I miss in that meeting?” The opposite is avoidance. After a hard Sunday, you go quiet and hope nobody brings it up. The Sundays you least want to discuss are the ones most worth discussing.
5. Receptivity. Feedback and criticism are often the same words landing on different ears. When you know you gave a task everything you had, correction stings, and the reflex is to explain yourself. I’ve done it mid-conversation, not noticing I had stopped listening. Excuses feel like explaining context. They’re not. Every minute you spend defending the decision is a minute you’re not learning from it.
6. Implementation. This is where it happens, or it doesn’t. Knowing is the easy half. Your calendar is the enemy here, because Sunday arrives whether or not you got around to the change. Put it on the schedule. Tell someone who will ask you about it. Otherwise, you’ll end up with a notebook full of wisdom and a ministry that looks exactly like it did last year.
None of this is new to Scripture. “Get all the advice and instruction you can, so you will be wise the rest of your life” (Proverbs 19:20, NLT). Note the verb. Get. Wisdom does not come find you in your study. You go after it.
Maybe coachability isn’t so much about your innate capacity to benefit from a coach. Maybe it’s just your capacity to improve at all. The most self-directed pastors I know score high on all six of these frames. Which means the better question isn’t, “Am I coachable?” It’s, “Will this coach pull these six things out of me?”
Posted on November 16, 2026
Dr. Sam Rainer serves as president of Church Answers and as the lead pastor at West Bradenton Baptist Church in Bradenton, Florida. He writes, teaches, speaks, and consults on a variety of church health issues. Sam cohosts the popular podcast Rainer on Leadership.
Sam is the author of several books, including “The Church Revitalization Checklist,” “Understanding the Bible as a Whole,” and “The Surprising Return of the Neighborhood Church.” He has written hundreds of articles for several publications and is a frequent conference speaker on church health issues.
Sam holds a BS in finance and marketing from the University of South Carolina, an MA in missiology from Southern Seminary, and a PhD in leadership studies from Dallas Baptist University. He lives in Bradenton with his wife and four children.
More from Sam

